Final Report of Panel of Experts on Iran Established Pursuant to Resolution 1929 (2010)

June 5, 2014

Weapon Program: 

  • Nuclear
  • Missile
  • Military

Mentioned Suspect Entities & Suppliers: 

The Panel submits this report less than two months before the deadline set by the Joint Plan of Action for the conclusion of a comprehensive agreement between the Islamic Republic of Iran and its counterparts in the E3+3, with expectations high that a comprehensive solution is within reach. The prospect of such a solution has dramatically shifted the context in which the Panel works. The Joint Plan of Action, which entered into force in January 2014, provides the Islamic Republic of Iran with limited, targeted relief from certain unilateral or multilateral sanctions. The International Atomic Energy Agency has reported that, to date, the Islamic Republic of Iran has fulfilled its “voluntary measures” agreed to under the Joint Plan of Action.

A challenge for States during this period of intense negotiation and, should it occur, implementation of a comprehensive solution, will be to maintain clarity with respect to State obligations under existing Security Council sanctions. Some States have indicated to the Panel a degree of uncertainty as to whether Security Council resolutions concerning the Islamic Republic of Iran remain fully in force. One source of uncertainty concerns the status of obligations regarding procurement related to uranium enrichment by the Islamic Republic of Iran, should such activities continue under a comprehensive solution.

The Panel investigated more than two dozen cases during this mandate involving alleged violations of resolution 1929 (2010) and prior resolutions. The majority of incidents concern the attempted procurement of dual-use items.

Most of those items, with some exceptions, fall below established control thresholds. Their identification remains a challenge to the implementation of Security Council sanctions intended to target Iranian procurement of goods and materials for prohibited activities. On the basis of the cases investigated by the Panel and information made available by States, it is increasingly difficult for authorities to identify links between below-threshold items and prohibited end users or end uses in the Islamic Republic of Iran. This may be a function of more sophisticated procurement strategies on the part of the Islamic Republic of Iran, which has developed methods of concealing procurement, while expanding prohibited activities. Such methods can also be used by the Islamic Republic of Iran to procure and finance legitimate trade, which further complicates the efforts of States to identify illicit procurement.

The Islamic Republic of Iran has continued to engage in ballistic missile activities. It is reported to have conducted a number of ballistic missile test launches over the past year, which are a violation of paragraph 9 of resolution 1929 (2010). It is also developing its launch capabilities: a new launch site near the city of Shahrud was identified. At the same time, the Islamic Republic of Iran decided to forgo its 2013 Great Prophet military exercises, during which numerous ballistic missiles have traditionally been launched.

Member States and media have continued to report allegations of ongoing arms transfers by the Islamic Republic of Iran. During the current mandate, the Panel investigated one case of an attempted transfer by the Islamic Republic of Iran of conventional arms and related materiel. The actions of the Islamic Republic of Iran in this respect stand in contrast to the apparent restraint it has shown in other areas of prohibited activities.

Several States have conveyed to the Panel their assessment that there has been a decrease in the number of detected attempts by the Islamic Republic of Iran to procure items for prohibited programmes, and related seizures, since mid-2013. While the Panel cannot confirm this development independently, because of delays between incidents and their subsequent reporting to the Committee, it is possible that this decrease reflects the new political environment in the Islamic Republic of Iran and diplomatic progress towards a comprehensive solution.